My 2017 proposal to realign NCHSAA classes & playoffs
I have a proposed system that I believe will greatly improve the conferences
and playoffs in North Carolina.
1) First of all, I believe we need to realign to a 6-CLASS SYSTEM, 6A being
largest and 1A being smallest. I created conferences this way: I took the
2016 ADM numbers (student population) and added a 25% penalty for all
charter and perochial schools. I then divided up the classes by football-
playing schools (46 in each of 6A and 1A and 71 or so in 2A thru 5A). I
then added the non-football schools back in.
2) Playoffs: My proposed system would create 6 state champions in every
major sport. I would have 32 teams make the playoffs in 2A-5A and 24 in 1A
and 6A(32 in 1A sports where many charter schools participate).
Teams would qualify for the playoffs as follows: there would be automatic
qualifiers based on the number of teams in each conference using the formula
(x/2 - 1) and round up, where x is the number of teams in the conference.
Using this formula, conferences with 3-4 teams would get 1 automatic
qualifier(AQ), 5-6 teams would get 2 AQ'S, 7-8 teams would get 3 AQ's, and
9-10 teams would get 4 AQ's. In addition, this would be applied to each
division of a split conference. Each division leader in a split conference
will qualify automatically regardless of division size. The remaining
participants would be wildcards, which would be chosen by best overall
records, with head-to-head and then conference record as tiebreakers.
Seeding would occur as follows: Seed the teams in tiers. 1st place AQ's by
overall records with head-to-head and then conference records as tiebreakers,
followed by 2nd place AQ's, then 3rd place AQ's, then 4th place AQ's, then
wildcards. Split conferences will be seeded like any other conference,
that is, according to where a team finishes in the overall standings.
I believe this system would help more teams in NC compete against schools
of like size for championships.
Attached is a model of what the system might look like.
* = non-football-playing school
| 6A | | | 5A | | | 4A |
|
| Conference #1 | | | Conference #1 | | | Conference #1 |
|
| Hoke County | 2400 | | Hoggard(5A) | 1848 | | Hunt | 1351
|
| Richmond Senior | 2210 | | New Hanover(5A) | 1654 | | Rocky Mount | 1264
|
| Pinecrest | 2201 | | West Brunswick(5A) | 1407 | | Fike | 1230
|
| Lumberton | 2165 | | Topsail(5A) | 1393 | | Franklinton | 1148
|
| Britt, Jack | 1985 | | South Brunswick(4A) | 1144 | | Northern Nash | 1143
|
| South View | 1932 | | North Brunswick(4A) | 1109 | | Southern Nash | 1101
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #2 | | | Conference #2 | | | Conference #2 |
|
| Laney(6A) | 2283 | | Cardinal Gibbons | 1897 | | Jacksonville | 1363
|
| Ashley(6A) | 1955 | | Southeast Raleigh | 1816 | | West Carteret | 1251
|
| New Bern(5A) | 1716 | | Corinth Holders | 1793 | | Northside(Jacksonville) | 1192
|
| Conley, D.H.(5A) | 1657 | | Cleveland | 1646 | | Swansboro | 1118
|
| South Central(5A) | 1612 | | Knightdale | 1643 | | Havelock | 1077
|
| Rose, J.H.(5A) | 1503 | | Clayton | 1633 | | White Oak | 1061
|
| | | | Harnett Central | 1511 | | |
|
| | | | East Wake | 1400 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #3 | | | Conference #3 | | | Conference #3 |
|
| Enloe | 2813 | | Overhills | 1832 | | West Johnston | 1389
|
| Garner | 2619 | | Swett, Purnell | 1717 | | Triton | 1341
|
| Rolesville | 2078 | | Pine Forest | 1676 | | Aycock, C.B. | 1263
|
| Wakefield | 2004 | | Seventy-First | 1634 | | Smithfield-Selma | 1241
|
| Wake Forest | 1991 | | Scotland | 1623 | | South Johnston | 1223
|
| Heritage | 1916 | | Cape Fear | 1589 | | Southern Wayne | 1087
|
| | | | Western Harnett | 1458 | | Eastern Wayne | 1049
|
| | | | Sanford, Terry | 1408 | | |
|
| | | | Northwood | 1407 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #4 | | | Conference #4 | | | Conference #4 |
|
| Broughton | 2683 | | Riverside(Durham)(5A) | 1826 | | Lee County | 1551
|
| Leesville Road | 2523 | | Hillside(5A) | 1589 | | Gray's Creek | 1508
|
| Cary | 2439 | | Southern Durham(5A) | 1585 | | Union Pines | 1360
|
| Millbrook | 2408 | | Northern Durham(5A) | 1562 | | Westover | 1319
|
| Athens Drive | 2153 | | Chapel Hill(5A) | 1532 | | Byrd, Douglas | 1318
|
| Sanderson | 1935 | | East Chapel Hill(4A) | 1376 | | Smith, E.E. | 1276
|
| | | | Person(4A) | 1323 | | Southern Lee | 1154
|
| | | | Orange(4A) | 1201 | | St. Pauls(3A playing up) | 986
|
| | | | Cedar Ridge(4A) | 1159 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #5 | | | Conference #5 | | | Conference #5 |
|
| Green Hope | 2786 | | Southern Alamance | 1574 | | Asheboro | 1362
|
| Panther Creek | 2720 | | Smith, Ben L. | 1573 | | Eastern Guilford | 1335
|
| Middle Creek | 2301 | | Dudley | 1532 | | Western Alamance | 1286
|
| Fuquay-Varina | 2241 | | Northern Guilford | 1466 | | Eastern Alamance | 1265
|
| Apex Friendship | ~2200 | | Southeast Guilford | 1432 | | Northeast Guilford | 1189
|
| Holly Springs | 2088 | | Western Guilford | 1397 | | Williams | 1172
|
| Apex | 2045 | | | | | Southwestern Randolph | 1060
|
| Jordan | 2025 | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #6 | | | Conference #6 | | | Conference #6 |
|
| West Forsyth(6A) | 2376 | | Southwest Guilford | 1725 | | Rockingham County(4A) | 1173
|
| Northwest Guilford(6A) | 2237 | | High Point Central | 1703 | | North Forsyth(4A) | 1162
|
| Page(6A) | 2128 | | Ragsdale | 1643 | | Southern Guilford(4A) | 1144
|
| Reagan(6A) | 1978 | | Parkland | 1639 | | McMichael(4A) | 1054
|
| Reynolds, R.J.(5A) | 1824 | | Mount Tabor | 1600 | | Morehead(3A) | 1003
|
| East Forsyth(5A) | 1816 | | Glenn | 1577 | | West Stokes(3A) | 901
|
| Grimsley(5A) | 1761 | | | | | Atkins(3A) | 861
|
| Davie County(5A) | 1756 | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #7 | | | Conference #7 | | | Conference #7 |
|
| South Mecklenburg | 3145 | | Rocky River | 1820 | | Piedmont | 1375
|
| Ardrey Kell | 3064 | | Porter Ridge | 1740 | | Weddington | 1361
|
| Myers Park | 3057 | | Hickory Ridge | 1714 | | Robinson, Jay M. | 1321
|
| Olympic | 2664 | | Central Cabarrus | 1704 | | Concord | 1267
|
| Garinger | 2296 | | Cox Mill | 1688 | | Carson | 1236
|
| Providence | 2119 | | Marvin Ridge | 1666 | | Northwest Cabarrus | 1235
|
| West Mecklenburg | 1992 | | Cuthbertson | 1547 | | Monroe | 1180
|
| Berry Academy | 1964 | | Sun Valley | 1450 | | Parkwood | 1159
|
| | | | | | | West Rowan | 1076
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #8 | | | Conference #8 | | | Conference #8 |
|
| Mallard Creek | 2682 | | Mooresville | 1874 | | Ashbrook | 1370
|
| Hough | 2639 | | Vance | 1871 | | Kings Mountain | 1269
|
| Independence | 2568 | | Lake Norman | 1869 | | Crest | 1213
|
| North Mecklenburg | 2291 | | Hopewell | 1766 | | Forestview | 1177
|
| Butler | 2195 | | Harding | 1755 | | North Gaston | 1166
|
| East Mecklenburg | 1970 | | West Charlotte | 1752 | | Huss, Hunter | 1104
|
| | | | South Iredell | 1653 | | Cramer, Stuart | 1051
|
| | | | Charlotte Catholic | 1550 | | South Point | 1047
|
| | | | Kannapolis Brown | 1539 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | Conference #9 | | | Conference #9 |
|
| | | | McDowell | 1859 | | Watauga | 1373
|
| | | | South Caldwell | 1773 | | Statesville | 1303
|
| | | | Roberson, T.C. | 1650 | | St. Stephens | 1255
|
| | | | Erwin | 1496 | | North Iredell | 1174
|
| | | | Alexander Central | 1444 | | Freedom | 1172
|
| | | | Reynolds, A.C. | 1439 | | Hickory | 1073
|
| | | | | | | West Caldwell | 1070
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | Conference #10 |
|
| | | | | | | Asheville | 1364
|
| | | | | | | Enka | 1254
|
| | | | | | | North Buncombe | 1228
|
| | | | | | | North Henderson | 1096
|
| | | | | | | West Henderson | 1077
|
| | | | | | | Tuscola | 1063
|
| 3A | | | 2A | | | 1A |
|
| Conference #1 | | | Conference #1 | | | Conference #1 |
|
| Nash Central | 1044 | | Currituck(3A) | 1014 | | Gates County | 519
|
| Washington | 1024 | | Hertford County(3A) | 839 | | Manteo | 502
|
| West Craven | 971 | | Northeastern(2A) | 819 | | Perquimans | 494
|
| North Pitt | 945 | | Pasquotank(2A) | 803 | | Plymouth | 330
|
| Southwest Edgecombe | 863 | | Bertie(2A) | 766 | | Cape Hatteras | 185
|
| Beddingfield | 827 | | First Flight(2A) | 760 | | Columbia | 168
|
| | | | Camden County(2A) | 607 | | Mattamuskeet | 117
|
| | | | Edenton Holmes(2A) | 606 | | Creswell | 85
|
| | | | | | | Ocracoke* | 56
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #2 | | | Conference #2 | | | Conference #2 |
|
| Roanoke Rapids(3A) | 976 | | Greene Central | 809 | | Northampton County | 461
|
| Bunn(3A) | 938 | | South Lenoir | 783 | | KIPP Pride Academy | 441
|
| South Granville(3A) | 937 | | Kinston | 766 | | Northwest Halifax | 437
|
| Webb(3A) | 875 | | Goldsboro | 760 | | Rocky Mount Prep | 365
|
| Southern Vance(3A) | 842 | | Farmville Central | 727 | | Weldon | 345
|
| Northern Vance(3A) | 840 | | Ayden-Grifton | 703 | | Southeast Halifax | 299
|
| Granville Central(2A) | 721 | | Tarboro | 609 | | North Edgecombe | 240
|
| Warren County(2A) | 650 | | Riverside(Williamston) | 564 | | |
|
| Louisburg(2A) | 607 | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #3 | | | Conference #3 | | | Conference #3 |
|
| East Duplin | 963 | | Trask | 756 | | Southside | 449
|
| Richlands | 940 | | Southwest Onslow | 753 | | Pamlico | 436
|
| Croatan | 911 | | Kenan, James | 707 | | Northside(Pinetown) | 435
|
| Clinton | 889 | | Wallace-R.H. | 674 | | Lejeune | 403
|
| Dixon | 882 | | Pender | 597 | | Jones Senior | 329
|
| North Lenoir | 870 | | East Carteret | 590 | | South Creek | 267
|
| | | | Lakewood | 544 | | Bear Grass Charter* | 256
|
| | | | Union | 542 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #4 | | | Conference #4 | | | Conference #4 |
|
| Cummings | 957 | | Red Springs(2A) | 795 | | North Johnston(2A) | 809
|
| Randleman | 876 | | South Columbus(2A) | 792 | | Midway(2A) | 761
|
| Jordan-Matthews | 847 | | West Bladen(2A) | 770 | | Spring Creek(2A) | 693
|
| Graham | 843 | | Fairmont(2A) | 720 | | Hobbton(2A) | 541
|
| Yancey, Bartlett | 842 | | Whiteville(2A) | 715 | | Rosewood(1A) | 533
|
| Providence Grove | 830 | | East Bladen(2A) | 651 | | Princeton(1A) | 526
|
| Carrboro | 822 | | West Columbus(1A) | 472 | | North Duplin(1A) | 357
|
| | | | South Robeson(1A) | 468 | | Neuse Charter(1A)* | 299
|
| | | | East Columbus(1A) | 428 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #5 | | | Conference #5 | | | Conference #5 |
|
| North Davidson | ~1000 | | Reidsville | 812 | | Raleigh Charter(2A)* | 704
|
| Ledford | ~1000 | | West Davidson | 786 | | NCSSM(2A)* | 680
|
| Oak Grove | ~1000 | | Walkertown | 785 | | Research Triangle(2A)* | 637
|
| Central Davidson | 988 | | Lexington | 776 | | Franklin Academy(2A)* | 632
|
| Andrews, T.W. | 984 | | Trinity | 774 | | Voyager Academy(1A)* | 512
|
| East Davidson | 940 | | Carver | 743 | | Roxboro Comm.(1A)* | 510
|
| Wheatmore | 832 | | Eastern Randolph | 743 | | East Wake Academy(1A)* | 407
|
| | | | Thomasville | 700 | | Oxford Prep(1A)* | 289
|
| | | | Uwharrie Charter* | 656 | | Woods Charter(1A)* | 227
|
| | | | | | | River Mill(1A)* | 205
|
| | | | | | | Falls Lake Academy(1A)* | 175
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #6 | | | Conference #6 | | | Conference #6 |
|
| Central Academy | 1044 | | West Wilkes | 790 | | South Stanly | 518
|
| East Rowan | 1044 | | Surry Central | 786 | | Union Academy | 484
|
| Forest Hills | 1029 | | North Wilkes | 743 | | Albemarle | 451
|
| Lake Norman Charter | 1007 | | East Surry | 632 | | South Davidson | 430
|
| Anson | 969 | | Starmount | 603 | | Chatham Central | 410
|
| South Rowan | 947 | | East Wilkes | 584 | | Chatham Charter* | 235
|
| Mount Pleasant | 878 | | South Stokes | 538 | | Carolina International* | 220
|
| Salisbury | 836 | | | | | Bradford Prep* | 212
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #7 | | | Conference #7 | | | Conference #7 |
|
| Burns | 1044 | | West Stanly | 757 | | Mount Airy | 513
|
| North Lincoln | 975 | | East Montgomery | 662 | | Bishop McGuinness | 509
|
| East Gaston | 925 | | North Rowan | 612 | | Alleghany | 446
|
| East Lincoln | 898 | | Queen's Grant* | 601 | | North Stokes | 389
|
| West Lincoln | 851 | | North Stanly | 588 | | Elkin | 377
|
| Shelby | 845 | | Gray Stone Day* | 586 | | Winston-Salem Prep | 257
|
| Lincolnton | 836 | | North Moore | 583 | | |
|
| | | | West Montgomery | 557 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #8 | | | Conference #8 | | | Conference #8 |
|
| Foard, Fred T. | 993 | | Lincoln Charter* | 810 | | Murphy | 495
|
| Newton-Conover | 979 | | Pine Lake Prep | 765 | | Hayesville | 389
|
| Patton | 955 | | Highland Tech | 694 | | Robbinsville | 378
|
| East Burke | 953 | | Bessemer City | 681 | | Rosman | 363
|
| Bunker Hill | 952 | | Comm. Sch. Of Dav. | 627 | | Cherokee | 312
|
| Maiden | 900 | | Mountain Island Charter | 599 | | Andrews | 248
|
| Bandys | 884 | | Cherryville | 536 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #9 | | | Conference #9 | | | Conference #9 |
|
| Hibriten | 1014 | | Chase(2A) | 805 | | Hiwassee Dam* | 187
|
| Wilkes Central | 984 | | East Rutherford(2A) | 712 | | Tri-County EC* | 182
|
| West Iredell | 952 | | Draughn(2A) | 685 | | Blue Ridge* | 124
|
| Ashe County | 936 | | Avery County(2A) | 601 | | Highlands* | 117
|
| Forbush | 874 | | Mitchell(1A) | 506 | | Nantahala* | 28
|
| North Surry | 871 | | Jefferson, Thomas(1A) | 434 | | (combined with conference #8 in certain sports)
|
| | | | Piedmont Comm.(1A)* | 421 | | |
|
| | | | | | | |
|
| Conference #10 | | | Conference #10 | | | Independents |
|
| Pisgah | 1014 | | Hendersonville | 795 | | ENCSD*, NCSD* |
|
| Franklin | 953 | | Brevard | 776 | | |
|
| East Henderson | 926 | | Madison | 776 | | |
|
| Smoky Mountain | 890 | | Mountain Heritage | 709 | | |
|
| Owen, C.D. | 861 | | Polk County | 642 | | |
|
| R-S Central | 845 | | Swain County | 556 | | |
|